Dogtra 1900S vs 1900X
Pick the Dogtra 1900X if you want the tougher metal case, a customizable BOOST button and stronger reported output; pick the 1900S if you prefer 127 graduated levels on a rheostat dial. Both run at 3/4 mile, IPX9K waterproof, for dogs 35 lbs and up.
Pros
- 1900X: tougher metal case, BOOST button, LED light
- 1900S: 127 levels on a fast rheostat dial
Cons
- 1900S: older platform, no BOOST button
- 1900X: 100 levels, fewer steps than the 1900S
The core difference
These are two generations of the same 3/4-mile class. The 1900S is the older high-output design: 127 levels, a rheostat dial, Nick, Constant and an HPP vibration, in a slim seamless receiver. The 1900X is the newer platform: 100 levels, Tone, Vibration and a customizable BOOST button, in a built-for-life metal case with a 1000-lux LED light. Owners who have used both report the 1900X as the hotter unit.
Specifications
| Spec | Detail |
|---|---|
| 1900S levels | 127 |
| 1900X levels | 100 |
| Range (both) | 3/4 mile |
| 1900X case | Metal, LED 1000 Lux |
| Waterproof (both) | IPX9K |
| Dog size (both) | 35 lbs and up |
Figures from each model's Amazon listing.
Popular options on Amazon
Prices change often - check the current price on Amazon.
What owners say
I'm pretty sure the dogtra 1900s is similar in size to the BOSS by ecollar tech. I have heard terrible things about the dogtra arc and dogtra IQ ...
r/OpenDogTraining
Which to choose
Choose the 1900X for the metal housing, BOOST button and LED light - the better all-weather hunting pick. Choose the 1900S if you want the finest level steps and the classic rheostat dial. Setup for either is on the how to use page.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is the 1900X stronger than the 1900S?
Do the 1900S and 1900X share parts?
Ready to check the latest price?
Check Price on Amazon